I got a similar response model is getting what MatCap as well. Also, I notice that whatever every object should appear bright the remaining three will render out duller than the selected.
Also, I notice that whatever SubTool happens to be selected, the remaining three will render out duller than the selected one. I got a similar response to my recent Tweet query as well. When I toggle off the texture hitting the paintbrush icon next to the eye in the SubTool I see that they all appear to have the same material, but when the textures are toggled on, the Shark and Turtle models are washed out.
